The very best olive oil is not just extra virgin, it is also unfiltered. A taste will show you why Italian peasents tend to be happier than fat, rich Americans. Unfortunately, unfiltered olive oil only has a shelf life of a few months before it becomes rancid. Make sure you check the date on the bottle or your pasta might taste like your nonna's underwear.
Editorial note: Whoa! You've found a super-old post here on BuzzFeed, from an earlier era of the site. It doesn't really represent where we are anymore, and may in fact be totally broken, but we're leaving it up as a part of our early history.